Oracle vs. Google: Intellectual Property Rights or Power?

Penulis: Ahmad Saiful Muhajir - detikinetJakarta - In mid-August and then, suddenly turned ugly in the world of Open Source. And again, this is about licensing. This problem is quite large because digelontorkan by big players, Oracle. Yes, Oracle sue Google over Android.
Oracle's global picture is to sue Google for allegedly violating intellectual property rights owned by Java. Java is a platform with an earlier patent held by Sun Microsystems. Because Sun Microsystems has been acquired by Oracle in January, so now the Java become the property and responsibility of Oracle.
Well, in the demands submitted by Oracle spokeswoman Karen Tillman, Oracle pointed out that in the development of Android, Google has directly and repeatedly violating intellectual property rights. Violation in question is Google's touted to have 'stolen' ideas and code from Java to be used in Android that is now becoming a trend in the smart phone market.
There are six patents that are used by Oracle to sue Google, namely (1) domain protection and access control, (2) methods and tools for processing and packaging, (3) model in the runtime process, (4) reference data and codes, (5 ) function and how to use the machine, and the last is (6) initialization method.
The question that arises is, what is there? Why Oracle's 'sudden' sue Google into court?
If judging, is nothing new from this case. James Gosling, the father of Java creator says 'no surprise' when asked for feedback on this case.
Initially
It all started when Sun make Java as open source in 2006 and then to develop a rear wing and Java. Since that time, Java was developed by the developers and Java technology is used in various companies to data centers. One of the big companies that helped develop Java is Google. In collaboration with other companies that also use and develop Java, Google and then become part of the Java Community Process (JCP). JCP is an agency in charge of making the standards for Java.
After several years running, comes the Java Micro Edition or better known as Java ME. Same as before, Sun is also liberating for Java ME developers. However, due to good market, Sun persuade big companies that want to develop Java ME to buy a license and each company is free to make any product from Java ME. These companies include Nokia, Research In Motion (RIM), Motorola, LG, Samsung, Vodafone and T-Mobile.
Seeing the smart phone market in the future is good enough, Google does not want to lose that in 2007 Google bought Android and established the Open Handset Alliance along with other big companies like NVidia, Sony Ericsson, Samsung and others to shelter Android. The path taken by Google is somewhat subtle because although utilizing Java technology, Google has no obligation to pay a license or deal with it.
Starting from where the problems arise, and since then the Sun-Google trying to make a collective agreement but did not also get a way out even if lasts for more than 3 years.
Actually Problems
Actually the problem is not in Android, but on the Dalvik Virtual Machine (Dalvik). Dalvik is an independent virtual machine, new and made specifically for Android. Dalvik is the product of 'derivatives' of the Apache Harmony that in fact came from Java. Well, although Dalvik is a virtual machine in a completely new all at once different from the Java Virtual Machine, but almost most (if not all) libraries in Dalvik taken from Java.
This is a different way that benefits Google, plus one day into Android smart phone operating system world-wide and almost beat the IOS. This is what makes Sun's hurt because of Android makes Java ME products did not sell. Gain from sales of licenses Java ME that is down.
Unfortunately, bringing the case to court to win not the nature of the Sun. Sun is a company focusing on development and not (too)-oriented business. Well, when the Sun eventually was acquired by Oracle, even this problem of getting support and fresh air. Because Oracle is the company that put the business back then Oracle raised this issue and brought to justice.
Judging from history, then there are two possible motives for Oracle claims Google. The first is to uphold the Java license and the second is power and money. But if you look at the history and journey of this case, the last motive appears to be more strongly coupled background Oracle. With the power of Google in its Open Handset Alliance and the rapid sales of Android, it is natural that Oracle finally feel jealous and want both.
In addition, the release of James Gosling and Jonathan Schwartz also could be an omen. Both elders Sun is decided out of the Oracle shortly after Sun bought. In one occasion, each also acknowledged during the process of negotiating the acquisition of Oracle talks about this case.
Now, suppose that Oracle has won this case they will get two things at once is power and money. Who would not want both of these?